Appearances: 13 (1995, 1996, 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2003, 2004, 2006, 2018, 2019, 2023, 2025)
Overall Record: 15-13

2025
First Round: Western New England 83, Hamilton 73

2023
First Round: Hamilton 84, Montclair State 75
Second Round: Johns Hopkins 81, Hamilton 71

2019
First Round: Hamilton 72, Penn State Behrend 70
Second Round: Hamilton 83, Moravian 72
Third Round: Christopher Newport 75, Hamilton 67

2018
First Round: Hamilton 86, Nazareth 72
Second Round: Hamilton 69, York 66
Third Round: Springfield 92, Hamilton 90 (OT)

2006
First Round: Hamilton 66, Plattsburgh 65 (OT)
Second Round: Amherst 83, Hamilton 59

2004
First Round: St. John Fisher 90, Hamilton 83

2003
First Round: Hamilton 93, Colby-Sawyer 68
Second Round: Hamilton 72, St. John Fisher 68
Third Round: Williams 76, Hamilton 65

2000
First Round: Hamilton 85, Endicott 68
Second Round: Cortland 60, Hamilton 55

1999
First Round: Hamilton 66, Rochester 58
Second Round: Hamilton 72, St. John Fisher 70
Third Round: Trinity (Conn.) 89, Hamilton 73

1998
First Round: Hamilton 102, Geneseo 68
Second Round: Hamilton 87, St. John Fisher 72
Third Round: Williams 90, Hamilton 69

1997
First Round: Buffalo State 70, Hamilton 66

1996
First Round: St. Lawrence 85, Hamilton 78

1995
First Round: Hamilton 83, Plattsburgh 74
Second Round: Hamilton 79, Buffalo State 64
Third Round: NJIT 96, Hamilton 86

1994
First year NESCAC schools are allowed to participate in the NCAA playoffs